Alternative treatment vs. traditional medical care

I wrote this more than a year ago. I didn’t have many readers then and now I have a lot of readers who have never read most of what I wrote in the early months. So today I’m publishing a piece I first wrote in May of 2007.

Here it is—-I’ve edited and changed it a bit:

I often site anecdotal evidence for much of what I talk about on this site. I don’t get why people so very often are so obstinately opposed to considering anecdotal evidence. I know the reasons they give but they don’t hold up under scrutiny.

The hard-core scientific, “evidence based” believers in the world of psychiatry and medicine refuse to accept anecdotal evidence of efficacy of alternative most often “unstudied” treatments. They insist that until there is a valid double-blind systematic clinical study of something proving it to be true, nothing else can be valid. This is ridiculous and short-sighted. Granted an isolated few anecdotal stories should be questioned, but if there is a compelling anecdotal story and once you dig deeper there are more and more of those stories you should start wondering if something is valid.

Clinical trials cost money and they cost a lot of money. Pharmaceutical companies have that money and they come out with all sorts of supposedly reliable evidence. As most of us know, however, much of the data in these studies are manipulated and massaged into what the pharmaceutical company wants the data to say. Just spend some time on Cl Psych’s website, or Philip Dawdy’s Furious Seasons. Go into the pharma blogosphere for more evidence. An easy example of this, commonly known, is how antidepressants tend to perform only about 2 points better than placebo and still get hailed as wonder drugs. If you take a closer look at the studies the slight performance over placebo has to be questioned as well. Read Grace Jackson’s Rethinking Psychiatric Drugs for a closer look at how trials are done and how people who might negatively effect positive outcome for drugs are often let go and not even allowed in the study. We have no reason to trust clinical trials done by pharmaceutical companies in most cases. So I don’t trust clinical trials in general. I’m not saying there are no credible trials, of course that is not true, but one has to study the study carefully to know how credible they are.

On the other hand I have come to seriously consider anecdotal stories. At this point I have hundreds of examples of people who have responded to alternative treatments for mental health. First I had to entertain that the early stories I became aware of might have validity. I did not immediately assume each and every story was conclusive of anything. But over time, scouring over websites, participating in email groups, reading countless books and then finally experiencing anecdotal relief myself, I can no longer deny that anecdotes are powerful evidence when accumulated en masse.

There are some alternative treatments that have been studied. Fish oil to treat mental anguish is now considered viable since there has been clinical trials. But the vast majority of alternatives have no studies. Who is going to pay to see if a healthy lifestyle with all it’s many components cures? No one. You just have to try it yourself. (yes there has been some studies for individual foods and simply lifestyle changes like exercise, for example, the health qualities of individual food properties like anti-oxidants or the beneficial qualities of fiber) These studies are actually done all the time, but they get drowned out by pharmaceutical marketing. Money is simply limited when it comes to studying extensively and then especially when it comes to marketing alternatives. Neither is done enough and it never will be as long as we as a society are beholden to traditional medicine.

It’s a shame so many people are missing out of viable, safe, effective alternatives to toxic drugs. This is true in all medicine, not just psychiatric medicine.

In addition what’s also unfortunate is that even some of the most vocal and informed critics of big pharma don’t venture into the realm of alternatives either. They bitch and moan about the status quo but offer no options other than reforming the current scientific system or worse yet going off drugs and living with very difficult symptoms when it’s entirely possible to heal. I don’t argue reform can be helpful, not all traditional medicine is bad–certainly I’m not suggesting we throw it all out–but there is more–yes there is more. And when it comes to psychiatry I do think it’s possible that most of it needs to be thrown out. And if we as a society were responsible about health care we would include serious scientific study of alternatives. I know responsible science would shed light on the truth of alternatives.

Natural  holistic care is generally profoundly safer and it often gets at the core of the problem—thus real healing occurs—one need not be “maintained” on toxic drugs for the rest of their lives. Not just in psychiatry but in many areas of health. Pharma is in the business of maintenance medication—not healing. And they don’t want people to know how many chronic problems are completely curable with diet and lifestyle changes. It’s profoundly disturbing.

But there is no money in lifestyle changes and diet and nutrition and meditation—- all things that can’t be patented.

And then of course we are a culture of the quick fix….even when the quick fix is illusory. Most people aren’t willing to go for the real fix. It takes making changes that a lot of people simply don’t want to make.

About Monica Cassani

Author/Editor Beyond Meds: Everything Matters

8 Responses

  1. Wow. Powerful stuff.

    Gianna, thank you so much for putting this up. I really needed to see this today, and you said it beautifully.

    Thank you!

  2. Thans for posting this again. I do not think I saw this before.

    The drug companies want double blind studies, but many of such studies have proven that antidepressants are at best no better than sugar pills. When all the studies are put together, the antidepresants are no better than sugar pills. Also, in recent years many good double blind studies have showed that exercise and cognitive therapy are just as good too. My pet resentment about this is that people are usually only given the option of being drugged up, when other proven alternatives are available.
    Jim S

  3. What baffles me most all the time is hearing them go on and on about that they practise what they call “evidence based medicine”. Well, maybe there’s some evidence that the drugs work, if you look at published studies only. And maybe many never look at anything else, than what gets published. If at all they look themselves, and not just rely on what their colleagues and the pharmaceutical industry tell them. But if you expect to be called a real expert in your field, you’d have to look at the whole “elephant”, I’d say. And that includes very much both anecdotal stories, studies like the WHO ones, several other long term outcome studies (Harding, Harrow/Jobe, e.g.), and things like Mosher’s experience with Soteria.

    It’s like I said in my talk at the pre-hearing at Copenhagen, back in March. When I look at it (the “elephant”), there’s evidence for one thing: that alternatives on an overall scale work far better than medical treatment. And that evidence has been there for a long time, at least since the Quakers’ Moral Treatment in the beginning of the 19th century. Nevertheless, it gets continuously ignored. – While one of the attending “experts” afterwards in a mail to the organizer, a friend of mine, called me a Scientologist…

  4. Hello,
    I have ventured into acupuncture, polarity and herbs.Skullcap and oatgrass or oatseed(same) will put you back to sleep at night. We all know about that!!!
    Have compassion for yourself. Forgive yourself and seek peace.It starts with one person.

  5. nearlynormalized

    Mind, body and soul and the will. I will not negate Western medicine, but the history of care from grandmothers, shamans and other traditional healers have worked wonders and heal thyself is what my message is to those that get tired of the HMO non communicative physicians. Check out this company,

Comments are closed.